We have been working our way through the Keurig Variety pack that Derrick’s mom gave us with our Keurig coffee maker. We’ve been trying one or two flavors a week for the past two months. We have tried to be as scientific about it as possible, though we’re the first to admit we don’t REALLY know anything about coffee. Here are our rankings of the flavors:

Gloria Jean’s Coffee – Hazelnut
R 3.5
D 3.5

Donut Shop
R 2
D 2

Green Mountain – Nantucket Blend
R 2
D 3.5

Green Mountain – Breakfast Blend
R 3.75
D 3

Twinings Earl Grey
R 0
D 1.5

Emeril Big Easy Intense
R 0.5
D 0.5

Van Houtte French Vanilla
R 3
D 3.5

Caribou – Caribou Blend
R 1
D 1

Timothy Italian Blend
R 0.5
D 0

Caribou – Daybreak Morning
R 2.5
D 3

Green Mountain – Sumerian Reserve
R 1
D 1.5

Green Mountain – Dark Magic Magic Noire
R 1.5
D 1

We’d love to hear more Keurig rankings/reviews from other coffee drinkers!